Heid keen to return to toon

Get this clown out. I wouldn't even take him in my 5 and 7 a side teams and I'm not kidding. He's too slow, he lacks a decent football brain and can't even lift/motivate the team when we're playing this badly even with his motor mouth of a gub.

Cyee

 

M74 then A69 across Gary, watch out for the speed cameras

:bbpd:

 

McGeady is a good dribbler and not very good at anything else. He is unlikely to ever be a seriously top level player. He has too many weakness in his game, the worst of which is a poor football brain.

OD is not even convincing on his loan. Has been to blame for a number of goals and benched. Two Cetlic managers in a row rate OD 4th choice CB behind some poor ones. That says all you need to know about OD. He just lacks the dominance and positional sense of a CB that even ordinary SPL CBs like the ones at Dundee United have in spades.

 

I know you keep saying this & in some ways I agree with you, especially his ranking as 4th placed CB under 2 managers.

But I can't agree with the dominance aspect you continue to mention, if you mean his physical presence then I have to disagree - he is really quite the muscular/athletic type of CB, very broad & looks pretty tall.

He's also not at all scared of getting stuck in, he was at LB against Killie last season & Taouil was giving Mick all sorts of issues - O'Dea came through him like a * train (winning the ball) & we didn't see much of Taouil again - in fact I think Jeffries pulled him for Connor Sammon for some extra weight.

O'Dea really impressed me that night & made me feel he could do a job at CB - but I agree he's not the finished article, hence why he went out on loan.

The fact he was given a new 3 year contract, makes me think Mowbray sees something in him too - I won't be surprised if he comes back into the team in Jan. His long ball distribution is also very good, better than Caldwell's.

 

Yeah would accept any decent bid for him.

 

How much are we having too pay Newcastle to take him off our hands and if we double it will they take McManus as well please.