McGeady v Hibs

Ref said he dived and in the replays it sure looks like he did.

Should Celtic throw the book at him????

 

Yes. We can't complain about it on the Wednesday and just let it go when it happens to our player on the Sunday.

 

Fine him. No need for the club to suspend him as he's already going to miss the United match now.

 

He dived, but never a yellow card. That McDonald guy was showing cards for fun today.

 

As painfull as it may be, Mcgeady needs to be punished for his actions.We cannot take the higher ground when players from other teams do it against us, if we are not prepared to take action ourselves

 

He was running full pace at the player who is coming into him. he takes a stumble the other player also falls which shows there must be some sort of contact, the hibs player is not just going to fall over when there is no contact or he should be sent off to.

 

was a clear dive and should be fined two weeks wages , Skippy should be warned about it too he was on his * atleast 4times and killen went down faster than Jordon's knickers

 

I think there was contact , as above said if there was no contact then why did the hibs player go down as well
Killen dived but mgeady did not

 

we need to set an example to anyone who dives in our team or we`ll look like fuds. what a * week.

 

mcgeady goes down to easy at times.....celtic need to act or we are as bad as * wenger.

 

clear dive, deserves a fine

killens wasnt bad, he got right back up & didnt look for a free kick

 

A dive is a yellow card.

 

Take your * green tinted specs off there was no contact clear * dive , any 1 trying to defend Mc Geady is a * .

 

Why did Hanlon go down it there was no contact?? From the replay you can see Hanlon's left foot make contact with McGeadys right foot. It wasn't the hardest of touches but McGeady was going full pelt so a slight touch was only needed for him to go down.

 

would have to agree, we cant shout at eduardo then defend our own for doing the same thing

 

Very Tough Game. Never easy going to easter road.

Don't know what McGeady was playin at. Deserves what he gets for diving after the Eduardo incident on Wednesday.

Same goes for Killen, How he got away with it i have no idea.

But dispite that. Glad we got all three points.

 

Come on, it was a harsh decision. It wasn't in the box or something so he could give yellow card so easily. Not many referees would give yellow to that. And I repeat, McDonald was giving cards too often.

 

gtf, if there was no contact then why the * did the hibs player go down and no get booked for "diving" ?

 

* you ya *. Aiden was running fast, he passes 2 players who try and take the legs off him. Another player comes flying in and looks like he is going to take aiden out. Aiden then goes down. Maybe there was no contact but what if aiden stands there and lets the player come in before going down? This has been completely blown out the water.

 

on the 1st angle shown ,hibs player is coming across to tackle, mcgeady skipped past one tackle bult up momentum then the second tackle came in the hibs player pulled out ,but had already whent in that close to mcgeady that he couldnt make a normal stride ,he leaned into mcgeadys left thigh which threw mcgeadys ballance thats my opinion, but you hav to ask why did the hibs player pull out cauz if mcgeady stays on his feet he is in a great position to go in on goal.