Scott Brown.....stay or go?

id say sell, if we got 8 mil for him, id laugh tht all the way to the bank

 

Keep him. I don't feel we've got enough strength in depth to be letting him go.

 

I like Broony but any offer over 8 mill id take.

 

I say keep him. Win the treble, Brown gets player of the year, we get 15Million and we get 2 top quality players in. - Thank you very much.

 

I said sell. £8m and Everton/Spurs can have him.

 

every player has his price

top £ and sell

cunty tactics by arry....keep him and tell the * to * off

 

I don't think we should sell him. But I think if the right bit comes in a good price, Hes off.

 

Any bid over £6m and he can go

 

He's been offerd to Everton

 

I'm in favour of selling, as I don't feel he fits with our new (but actually traditional) style of beautiful, inventive, passing football.

But I don't think now is the best moment. I'd keep him another 6 months to a year, wait till the time is right.

 

brooooooooooooooonyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

keep him hes one of were better players theres worse * in the squad

 

Source ?

 

Everton are preparing a £6m offer for Celtic midfielder Scott Brown.

The 24-year-old Scotland international was earlier this month linked with a £10m offer from Tottenham Hotspur.

It is understood that Everton had been approached by an agent offering Brown and Celtic defender Stephen McManus but said they were not interested.

However, having missed out on other targets, they are now poised to make a move after watching Brown facing Arsenal in the Champions League.

Brown, who was in the Celtic side that lost 3-1 at the Emirates on Wednesday, was bought by Celtic for £4.4m from Hibernian in 2007.

Everton and Spurs were thought to be interested in Brown at that time as Celtic beat a host of clubs, including Glasgow rivals Rangers, Bolton Wanderers, Middlesbrough and Reading, to the midfielder's signature.

Celtic reportedly turned down a £9m offer from Portsmouth in January.

But economic conditions have taken a downturn and the Scottish Premier League runners-up recently announced that their profits had halved.

Spurs manager Harry Redknapp this month admitted that he rated Brown, who ended the season as the SPFA Players' Player of the Year.

However, he played down suggestions that he was interested in signing a player who was also named among 14 players on world governing body Fifa's "ones to watch in 2009" list.

Brown, who won his 17th cap in Scotland's World Cup qualifying defeat by Norway, had recovered from a disappointing first season with Celtic during which he had to cope with injury, suspension and the death of his sister.

Like Brown, McManus missed the start of this season through injury and the Celtic captain has just returned to training in time to be linked with a move away from the club.

Celtic are believed to be willing to sell the 26-year-old or allow the Scotland defender to leave on loan, with Ipswich Town thought to be leading the interested clubs.

 

BBC SPORT | Football | My Club | C | Celtic | Everton eyeing up Celtic's Brown

 

if we sell him we will be struggiling in all our away games he might not score or assist every week but he wins the ball before it gets to the defence bullys midfeilds and drives us foward. Lose him and we wont be able to find a replacement without paying crazy wages

 

IMO Brown is a point in his career where he has to decide what type of player he is going to be to be. He simply dosen't cut it as an attacking midfielder, and as much as he and others like might like to think of him as a box-to-box player, he offers little in the way of cutting edge at the oppositions end of the park.

Personally, I think he should try to develope his game as a defensive midfielder providing a supporting element to attacking players going beyond him. This will require a huge amount on the training field to work on his passing abilty, which is quite frankly, appauling. At the moment he has very little other than physical attributes going for him.

I feel his value is depreciating by the month and any bid around £7M (I said above this previously) should be snapped up.

 

£10m = sell.

Buy a CM + CD £5m each.

I am sure he could be easily replaced for 5m and to get a good solid defender for 5m would be an added bonus.