Naylor, Donati, Killen, Sami?? Why ????

these players aint been good enough to pull on a celtic jersey for at least two year - - why now under new management ??


my heart nearly stopped when to save our big european chance our subs coming on were "killen n sami" :-( :-(

gonna have bad dreams tonight about it now

please mogga dont think these players are gonna be our bread winners

serious concerns bout the tactics ??

p.s.

why mcgeady playin right mid if he's been left mid for 4 year ??????

 

totally agree, naylor donati killen and samaras were all pish.
killen hardly won the ball at all.

 

the 4 shouldnt be near a celtic jersey..

today marked the start of the 14th year as a celtic season ticket holder at the new celtic park.

N I'll be honest " that display wiz the the worst performance i've ever seen in europe at celtic park"

Please sort this out mogga !!!

 

I think killen deserves a chance

Naylor should be dropped so fox can get settled in at LB

Donati didn't help his chances tonight

Mcgeady should stop behind after training and work on his final ball

Hinkel needs to stay behind after training and get booted up the * to move the f*ckin ball quicker.

mcLoovens needs to grow a pair and star attacking the ball Bobo style when its in the air.

 

Dont hold back now

 

Naylor was terrible.
Killen and Samaras were poor, but they only had the half hour to make an impact and sadly not alot came of it.
I think Donati was average and had a not bad spell in the first half, a bit like his old self. But, he had his moments were he was hiding from the ball and particularly in the second half - i feel thats why Mowbray substituted him.

I really think that the only reason they started/played is because Mowbray totally wiped the slate clean for these players and started afresh with them when he came in - regardless of the past seasons, and based on their pre season performances in which they played well (with the exception of Naylor maybe) he thought they deserved a chance.

However, having seen that they can't really cope with this pressure i don't think we'll be see as much of them as we thought. Certainly for big european games anyway.

Mowbray will sort this out.

 

i do believe hinkel is one of the positives.

killen is never a celtic player, neither is donati

naylor's had chance

sami is just no a striker.. p.s haircut

 

u can't disagree with any of it tho surely?

 

New manager sometimes needs to make all the same mistakes before working out a players weaknesses. I think WGS concluded none of them were first picks and Tony maybe needs time to work it out too, Re-inventing the wheel. I think he will come to the same conclusions as WGS about those players over the next month or so. The flaws of some players are hidden by some surface ability, especially Donati and Sammy but they are all have flaws and should be bench warmers unless they up their game.

 

he shouldnae have wiped the slate clean !!

surely he should've watched games from last few year

 

the thing is tho.....no CL = no new players IMO unless we sell

and the money we make from whatever * he ships out...aint gonna bring in one decent player, never mind 3-4 replacements.

Tino, different management styles work for different players

Moggas style could have worked perfectly for donati etc....no1 knows unless he tries it..

 

samaras n killen came on cause mcdonald n fortune were * and prob will b all season as fr mcgeady him and nguemo were best players on park so wat game are u watchin,maloney n caldwell pass marks but rest were *,diff season same old * well done celtic

 

Samaras hasn't been with us for 2 years.

 

Killen is a * donkey hes paid to attack the * Football not the goal keeper was lucky not to get sent off ,

 

Plus he spent 6 months as our super-sub, and around another good 6 months as a starter. He's been in the mix most of the time he's been here.
He was tearing opponents apart last year until his injury. I still think he's a footballer... but he needs to regain his form fast or move on.

* only knows why Naylor and Donati are still with the team at all.

 

Everyones a hero in preseason now after a game which we dominated and should have won but for poor finishing all these guys are pish? Get a * grip Donati did well Naylor was ok nowwhere near as bad as Hinkel and Loovens, Sami and Killen got * all service. Pathetic some of our so called fans

 

If mcgeady worked on his final ball he'd be f*ckin lethal.

instead he either goes for it (and 9 times out of 10 f*cks it up) OR he knocks it back to hinkel......who's half asleep...............and f*cks it up lol

 

the board let not only us down but the WGS down badly last jan when they thought league was won..

did the same after seville, after '98 , after the quality street gang "different board i may add"

under murray rangers went out to (blotter "*") us

tonights match was a right turn off for ah the fans!!

p.s

still having bad thoughts eh sami n killen running on

 

I think it was a * good game.

It just wasn't a good result.

 

donati?? what did he do??

naylor?? cross balls !!

we were all over them full match, final third was dreadful..

however these 4 are pish.. N i'll gee sami n killen there due they didn't get a decent run out tonight but surely you know and all the fans know these guys are * ????? surely, comon ???